With
the Democratic national convention just a few weeks away,
we move into that period of time occurring every four years
where political slogans and sound bites rain down-creating
the proverbial great flood of ancient times. Insistent campaign
promises, ranging from thoughtful to ridiculous will saturate
our eyes and ears over the next several months.
While
much of the political process is the zealous gathering of
support through emotional appeal, there is in fact some
quantitative basis underneath these rallying battle cries.
Here's
a summary look at the theoretical relationships between
government and money.
The
government has two major tools for achieving economic health:
fiscal policy, through which it determines the appropriate
level of taxes and spending; and monetary policy, through
which it manages the supply of money.
Since
the Depression, the federal government has tried to create
a combination of fiscal and monetary policies that will
allow sustained growth and stable prices (no inflation).
The
primary tools of fiscal policy are spending and taxation.
The deliberate manipulation of government purchases, including
military (funding a war, for example), public works projects,
scientific research are designed to achieve a balance between
full employment, price stability (restrain inflation), and
economic growth.
The
government has income from only one primary source-taxes.
Therefore manipulating tax rates, rules and structures,
tax incentives for certain activities (such as investment
in long-term assets) are designed to control both the income
level of the government and individual disposable income.
The
development of fiscal policy is an elaborate process. Each
year, the president proposes a budget, or spending plan,
to Congress. This is why budget issues are central to a
candidate's success. It will be the successful presidential
candidate who initiates the government spending process.
Virtually every campaign initiative will have an effect
on the budget.
Taxation
policy affects us more directly. The overall level of taxation
is decided through budget negotiations. Although the government
ran up deficits, (spending more than it collected in taxes)
during the 1970s, '80s, and the part of the '90s, the populous
generally believe budgets should be balanced.
Historically,
most Democrats are willing to tolerate a higher level of
taxes to support a more active government, while Republicans
generally favor lower taxes and smaller government. If you
keep all this in mind, it will help you to better evaluate
campaign promises and proposals.
Although
not nearly as emotionally evocative, monetary policy is
also central to the government's role in the economic life
of the nation. The job of managing the overall economy shifted
substantially from fiscal policy to monetary policy during
the later years of the 20th century.
The
Federal Reserve uses three main devices for maintaining
control over the supply of money and credit in the economy:
open market operations, the reserve level required by banks,
and the discount (interest) rate.
Although
not as obvious as interest rates, the most important is
open market operations, or the buying and selling of government
securities. To increase the supply of money, the Federal
Reserve buys government securities from banks, other businesses,
or individuals, paying for them with a check or a new source
of money that it prints.
Reserve
limits for deposit-taking institutions specify how much
money is set aside; either as currency in their vaults or
as deposits at their regional Reserve Bank. Raising reserve
requirements forces banks to withhold a larger portion of
their funds, thereby reducing the money supply.
The
discount rate or interest rate that commercial banks pay
to borrow funds from Reserve Banks is by far the most visible
tool used in monetary policy. It is the driver that ultimately
sets the amount of interest that business and individuals
will have to pay when borrowing money. By raising or lowering
the discount rate, the Fed can promote or discourage borrowing
and thus alter the amount of revenue available to banks
for making loans.
Mixing
these elements together isn't easy. Additionally, while
a strong economy may be a prerequisite to social progress,
it may not be the ultimate goal. The traditions of public
education, environmental regulations, rules prohibiting
discrimination, and government programs like Social Security
and Medicare, to name just a few - are also central to American
values.
The
late U.S. Senator Robert Kennedy explained in 1968, economic
matters are important, but gross national product "does
not include the beauty of our poetry or the strength of
our marriages; the intelligence of our public debate or
the integrity of our public officials. It measures neither
our wit nor our courage; neither our wisdom nor our learning;
neither our compassion nor our devotion to our country;
it measures everything, in short, except that which makes
life worthwhile."