December
is filled with magical holiday events - office parties,
family gatherings, concerts, annual correspondence with
friends, decorating and festive reminiscences of years gone
by.
But
for those of us focused on money, the most important event
is shopping.
Buying
presents, flying cross-country to visit relatives, having
special dinners and parties: Consumers spend more money
in the three months before the new year than at any other
time of the year. In fact, retailers often make about half
of their annual profit during this time, according to the
National Retail Federation.
Deloitte
LLP recently published its 2009 Annual Holiday Survey, which
gauges consumers' expectations about the year-end holidays,
the economic climate, and related spending and purchase
patterns. A total of $810 billion is expected to be spent
this year on holiday-related items. The full report may
be found at Deloitte.com
The
average consumer will spend $1,145 on items associated with
the holidays. About $452 of that will go to gifts, $102
to decorations and holiday home furnishings, $243 for socializing
away from home, $201 for entertaining at home and $147 for
clothing.
The
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports average consumer
income to be $63,500. Holiday spending is about 2 percent
of the average consumer's annual expenditures.
The National Retail Federation also publishes an annual
report on holiday retail sales. The report is online at
nrf.com.
At
the risk of feeding festive domestic discussions regarding
comparative spending habits, or for possible personal comparison,
the NRF is expecting the following expenditure levels in
these categories: gifts for family, $387; for friends, $67;
for co-workers, $19; other gifts, $35; decorations, $41;
greeting cards, $27; candy and food, $90; and flowers, $17.
However,
it's not just the amount of money spent that makes for a
robust economy; it's how fast it moves. Or in this case,
it's not just the one-time expenditure made by a single
consumer purchasing a fruitcake that fuels the economy;
it's where those dollars go after that transaction that
creates the multiplier effect.
Re-spending,
not simply spending is what propels economic stimulation.
As the money moves along the commerce chain, part of it
will be retained by the recipient, and part of it will be
re-spent by the next person or entity, multiplying the money's
original effect.
For
example, if there is an 80 percent re-spend rate, of the
$27 you pay for a box of greeting cards, the retailer from
whom you bought cards will pay $21.60 to the distributor,
who will pay $17.28 to the wholesaler, who then sends $13.82
to the printing company, which then pays $11.06 to paper
manufacturers, and on and on.
Thus
a single purchase of a $27 box of greeting cards is "multiplied"
into more than $106 of monetary activity. That's economic
stimulus - with one very important caveat. The re-spend
rate must be maintained throughout the chain.
What
can alter the re-spend rate in this series of transactions?
Financial intermediaries, which are people or institutions
between the producer and consumer that don't directly provide
proportional value. They're brokers, processing agents,
consolidators, re-sellers, arbitrage players, credit-card
companies, the private label in front of the credit-card
companies, retail lenders, wholesale lenders, pipeline financing
structures underneath lenders, insurance companies, etc.
If
borrowed money is involved, there are intermediaries. Too
many intermediaries sabotage the positive effect of the
multiplier.
It
follows then that any activity, from government stimulus
spending to our own $810 billion holiday extravaganza, will
be most effective when it avoids intermediaries that don't
contribute to the authentic production of good and services.
In other words, give your holiday money to those who will
pass it on.
One
key to making this year's holiday spending truly stimulating
is to spend without intermediaries. Past wisdom supported
some borrowing for holiday spending. After all, it did place
money into the financial systems through the multiplier.
Today we know this is a fragile assertion. Too many parasitical
intermediaries siphon off the process.
This
year, the lasting positive effect of holiday spending may
be not so much in how much is purchased, but what is purchased
and how.
The
less involvement by financial intermediaries, the greater
our own personal holiday economic-stimulus package will
be.